Screen Rant testing - Latest Comments in Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

John "Kahless" Taylor — Thu, 06 Nov 2008 17:19:38 -0000

Well, I actually liked last night's episode. I thought the plot was very similar to the Data and Lore plot from Star Trek: Next Generation. Can't wait to see KAR in action.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Lana — Sat, 27 Sep 2008 02:23:22 -0000

This show totally sucks!!! Bad plots, terrible acting, unbelievably corny lines, awful music...the worst show in history. I can't believe people actually paid money for this remake. It is nothing like the original...can't compare at all!!!

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

BruSimm — Sat, 27 Sep 2008 00:59:04 -0000

After watching the premiere, no wonder they released it a week early on the internet, then replayed it within a few days over on The Sci-Fi Channel.

Eesh. I don't think you're too far off on this one Vic!

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Vic Holtreman — Thu, 25 Sep 2008 22:51:53 -0000

@Ninja31

Thanks, although you should see some of my reviews when I really tear into something, lol. :-P

Vic

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

FlameStrike — Thu, 25 Sep 2008 21:32:19 -0000

Fair point, Psyko. I don't really remember who said what and when.

In any case, it may all come down to how much attention Billy was paying to the conversation and the events around him.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Ninja31 — Thu, 25 Sep 2008 20:33:37 -0000

Vic,

That was a very fair review of the show, I have a friend who is on that show and watched it to support'em and had similiar thoughts. The cast was upgraded from the pilot and that was nice to see, it was also good to see a more serious side of the lead instead of the one liners from the pilot. I really hope the best for this show and it would appear as if they have the right pieces in place to make it a while. If they make the (w)right changes!

Thanks for at least being fair Vic.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Psyko — Thu, 25 Sep 2008 19:03:34 -0000

"As for the complaint about Mike and Sarah having a separate oxygen supply and not suffocating when the fire does, they still could if they were in the vacuum chamber when their separate supply ran out. I don't see a huge plot hole there."

The trouble here is that Billy (funny how that was his name in BSG too) specifically notes that the heroes can't breath without air when they come up with the idea of putting them in the vacuum camber.

Charles Graiman: "We'll bring them into the tunnel. We'll shut the emergency doors; suck out all the air. Without oxygen, the fire can't breathe."

Billy Morgan: "Without oxygen, they can't breathe either."

You can argue that Billy wasn't talking about the oxygen running out due to a vacuum, but it'd be a huge stretch.

And, as for the special abilities, I'm cool with them. I don't mind the VTOL and all that jazz. I just wish they didn't make the CG so painful to watch.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

FlameStrike — Thu, 25 Sep 2008 13:15:52 -0000

Well, having finally seen the pilot for the series itself, I have to agree with a few of the gripes I've seen, and disagree with a few others.

First, I'll agree, the Mike-seeking missile was bad. Still, I got a laugh of it. The resulting fire being one that took advantage of KITT's self repair elements to continue fueling itself, though, was an interesting touch, and plays into the idea that there may be a leak inside from the Foundation.

As for the complaint about Mike and Sarah having a separate oxygen supply and not suffocating when the fire does, they still could if they were in the vacuum chamber when their separate supply ran out. I don't see a huge plot hole there.

As for the Turbo Boost, Merrill is correct, the original KITT did, on occasion, jump from a stationary position and clear obstacles. The trajectory guide function was shown being used to assist in that, so it's not without precedent.

So far, in fact, nothing shown in regard to KITT's abilities is without precedent. Everything he's done so far builds nicely on the original series and the abilities of the Knight 2000.

While the story didn't do much to build the characters, it did a nice job of reintroducing them after the pilot movie seven months ago. The passage of time within the show from the movie makes for a nice cushion that allows the development of the new abilities in the Knight 3000.

I like the fact that they seem to be setting up a possible recurring story line that can help with the depth of the show in future episodes. The possibility of a leak in the Foundation, something from Mike's past that he's forgotten may be back haunt him, and the possibility of the two being linked makes for some intriguing possibilities.

All in all, my biggest problem with the show was that they have such a large support team constantly monitoring everything going on in regards to the car. Nothing like this was ever established in the original series, giving the original Michael Knight a lot more freedom to operate since he didn't have Devon as a virtual back-seat driver. This element should really be toned down in future episodes.

Other than that, this series has definite potential, and I'm looking forward to seeing what the series is capable of once it gets free of the obstacles inherent in all first episodes of a series.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Mike — Thu, 25 Sep 2008 12:53:08 -0000

I grew up with Knight Rider being my hero. The theme song is my ringtone even to this day. I bought all the old episodes on DVD and rewatched them, enjoying them all. But back then, I was a kid. We didn't think about it making sense logically. I watched it as a serious show and I didn't even pick up the inuendos between Michael and the girls in the show, being too young.

Watching it now, I realize it is cheezy and it would never hold up to today's tv standards. But I know that if I was an 8 year old again, all those cheesy lighting effect and transformations would make me fall in love all over again. I'm not sure who knight rider's target audience was, but it mostly appealed to kids.

The new series is more of the same, except that the "naked" scene would have made my eyes bug out as an 8 year old =). Their target is still younger viewers, even though it has has some nods for the older ones. As an older and adult audience, it really isn't made for us. I too found the lack of oxygen thing to be very silly, much like I find the use of lasers in the original to be silly. I kind of wish they steped it up a notch and targed viewer who were fans of the orignal, rather than making it for kids. Star wars is suffering from the same problem, it's not growing with the audience.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Mat D — Wed, 24 Sep 2008 11:37:21 -0000

Let us not forget that the original series was hardly the great acting tome of our time...it mainly consisted of Hasselhoff driving around in his half open shirt, hitting on women and chasing around jewel thieves and blackmailers

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

$126191 — Sat, 20 Sep 2008 03:36:44 -0000

@TalynRider - I wouldn't be say "viewers are smarter", that's just a little arrogant; it's more like viewers expect a higher slightly standard of production now, in both writing and visual effects (though a lot of CGI around these days is just as cheesy as some of the effects work in the 1980s).

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Psyko — Fri, 19 Sep 2008 18:29:49 -0000

Spot on, Talyn. I was born mid-80's, so I can't sound off on the shows of that era, but I am well aware of what they're feeding us today. The new rendition could be classic Knight Rider to a "T," but, unless they want to only target the purely nostalgic type, that's not a terribly good thing. I wasn't even alive during the Knight Rider craze, so I didn't fall in love with the original. Sure, I've been able to see episodes, but missing out on the huge hoopla of the press and fans can really change how you perceive and accept a show. That's not to say that with enough press and big enough fan clubs any show can be generally accepted. Just to conjecture as to why it might be easier for an older generation to see worth in a show that somebody else, like me, sees as a complete mess.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Vic Holtreman — Fri, 19 Sep 2008 13:22:29 -0000

"I think part of the problem is that we aren’t in the 80’s anymore. We’ve seen what good shows in this genre can be and we’ve come to expect more."

Thank you - EXACTLY what I've been trying to say.

Also (and this is an important point), MANY of those 80s shows like Knight Rider, The A-Team, The Flash, etc. started out as SERIOUS shows (look at the first one or two episodes of each of those). But for some reason the pattern back in the 80s was for every one of those to fall into a "save the babe of the week whose scientist dad has been captured by bad guys and make it goofy."

Vic

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

TalynRider — Fri, 19 Sep 2008 12:23:13 -0000

I think part of the problem is that we aren't in the 80's anymore. We've seen what good shows in this genre can be and we've come to expect more. At it's start the original KR was new and different and the "cheese factor" was in many of the shows airing and became what we socially accepted for television programming. Now we expect/want more, we want some depth, we want decent effects, and because (and I say this with trepidation) the viewers are smarter now, we want it to make logical/scientific sense.
This new KR had a few moments that I thought were signs that there's hope. I actually like the truck mode and was surprised when it happened. The SPM is lame and I liked the Movie Pilot look better. KITT just looks like a box on wheels now (lets spend billions of dollars to make it look like a tuner?!?! that's cutting edge).
The characters and plot need time, I can see where they are going and the potential is strong. It might have a chance if they focus on simplifying the whole KITT thing a bit, stop trying to go over the top (less is sometimes more) and remember that they are working on a serial tv program otherwise they are bound to jump the shark before it's time.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Psyko — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 21:25:14 -0000

Perhaps they were some sort of Ion propulsion system that assist in the VTOL...

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Merrill — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 20:02:54 -0000

That I'm at a loss for. It was flash for flash sake there, probably just to grab the interest of the tuner bois.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Vic Holtreman — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 17:41:45 -0000

Also, in the "attack mode" I'd like to know what the purpose of the boy-racer neon lights under the car were. :-P

Vic

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Psyko — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 17:01:33 -0000

Please ignore the idiocy of the double "like to see reformed" statements. I didn't mean for the first one. It should have just been the "I love the idea of a..." part of that sentence.

I'm going back to bed now. I'm tired. :P

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Psyko — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 16:58:03 -0000

I'm all for "good, cheesy fun" and now that I know to view this as such, I'll give it another shot. I'm not seeing it do any better the second time around though because it's past cheesy and on to just painful. The copious amounts of subpar writing/acting are enough to send me away forever, but that's not all I have against it. Basic truths are ignored (my first comment) and the CG work is simply pathetic. With today's computers they have the power to do almost anything they want, in a very realistic manner. Instead they transform the only Mustang, on the planet, I'll refer to as good looking into a hideous beast and use poorly implemented effects to try to convince us it can fly, among other things. I'd love to see this show reformed to something I can sit through because I love the idea of a super advanced car that can do everything K.I.T.T. can do. I'm not so keen on the super advanced car looking like a teenage boy racer's ride with a glued on hood ornament and massive spoiler.

I'd love to see this show reformed and made into what it could be. A genuinely good show with one super bad-azz car and impressive tech that is borderline believable. Until then, I'm going to be sitting it out.

I don't know what Brimstone is, but I can totally agree with the rest of the statement Vic just quoted. I miss Firefly and could stand to never see mention of Big Brother ever again.

As before, I'll add my disclaimer that I'm not writing with any intention of belittling. Please read as somebody that is voicing their opinion and not attacking. Unfortunately the internet is not very good at conveying a message with the proper voice.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Vic Holtreman — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 16:41:45 -0000

"Then again you can have a great show with great writing that gets cancelled quickly like Firefly, and Brimstone, and tripe that stays on tv for years like Big Brother and Survivor."

On THAT point we agree. :-)

Sometimes there's no justice in the world of televsion.

Vic

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Merrill — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 16:24:01 -0000

Then again you can have a great show with great writing that gets cancelled quickly like Firefly, and Brimstone, and tripe that stays on tv for years like Big Brother and Survivor. People are really fickle and I think sometimes we give them too much credit at wanting well written, intelligent shows. Lost,and House are exceptions rather than the rule. Most of my viewing is done around the Discovery Channel or Sci-fi. The New Dr Who is a very good well done show. I just expect KR to last longer then TKR, but who knows with the ratings and just how many people agree with you who have the boxes. I don't have the box and I've seen lots of well written shows axed before their time. All in all this reminded me of what I remembered was so great about Knight Rider, Taking my evening a plopping down infront of the tv and watching a cool looking car do impossible things.

We're going to disagree on how we view this show, but they are only opinions and you've treated my very civily even though I don't agree with you.

Let's have a discussion like this again sometime. I think we've finished this one. :)

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Vic Holtreman — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 15:26:21 -0000

@Merrill

You can have a great show in ANY genre.

We'll see how long "good, cheesy fun" lasts.

Vic

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Merrill — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 14:58:02 -0000

Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to take it to you, just giving a second opinion on a show that I enjoyed and like I said it's alot better than past attempts to bring Knight Rider back.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Merrill — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 14:52:42 -0000

Besides Lost, Fringe, House, ect are all suspense Dramas, It would be like comparing Power Rangers with All My Children, although they are both shows you'd see on in the morning or afternoon ones for kids and ones a soap opera. Lost, House, Fringe are all serious dramas which deal with interweaving complex storylines. Knight Rider has always been about fun, formulaic plotlines and bad-guy of the week senarios. They just aren't in the same class, but you show with that statement that you're doing the show a favor by not lumping it in with them. You be very ignorant to lump it in with them because it is NOT the same type of show as they are. Which is what you're failing to get is that Knight Rider IS Knight Rider. It was Cheesy 80's fun brought to us by the man who did it better than no one else, Glen Larson. It was never and has never been deep thought provoking television, yet that's what old fans seem to have been expecting. Knight Rider was cheese. This Knight Rider IS Cheese. I think the producers nailed the spirit of the show, and that spirit of the show is what most of the old fans have forgotten because they are remembering it they way the want, not the way it was.

Re: Knight Rider Series Premiere Review

Merrill — Thu, 18 Sep 2008 14:44:51 -0000

Which they did several times in season 2 of the original it's called "Trajectory guide"